What Should My Pet Policy Include for Rental Properties?

Appfolio Websites • October 23, 2020

Renting to Pet Owners

Why don’t some landlords allow pets? As a landlord, you want to do everything possible to protect your investment, and sometimes, renting to tenants with pets adds all sorts of headaches that aren’t present with tenants who don’t have pets.


So why rent to pet owners at all? First of all, there are lots of them. Second, those pet owners love their animals and will always choose pet over property. Essentially, by choosing to ban pets from your property, you’re shrinking your pool of prospective tenants, and you could face higher vacancy rates — which landlords want even less than they want pets.


To help you navigate the pet issue as a landlord, here’s a look at key considerations and how to draft a pet clause in a lease agreement that helps protect your interests.


Create a Strong Tenant Screening System


Many landlords find themselves asking: Should I allow a pet in my rental property? That's not always the right question to ask, though. Perhaps a better one is: Am I securing the right tenants for my property? Good tenants are always going to take better care of your property than less than ideal ones, which is why tenant screening is so important. 


Start with good tenants, and you shouldn’t have a problem. You can add in other protections, such as limiting pets to dogs of a certain weight, but starting with great tenants should deliver results no matter what your rental pet policy includes.


Should I Allow Cats and Dogs in My Rental Property? 


Fortunately, there are a number of tools that landlords can use to protect themselves against the damage a pet can render in an apartment or other property. One way is with additional pet fees that help offset your risk. As mentioned, most people adore their pets, and they will understand the additional cost of keeping them on site. Consider a higher security deposit for people with pets, too. This will give you additional funds to cover any pet-related damage after a tenant moves out. You can also consider a “pet rent” that is just money added on for the presence of each pet during the life of the agreement.


All of this should be outlined in a pet lease addendum, a pet rental agreement or a similar document. Make sure you're clearly outlining expectations and policies before the tenants move in. Also, if a tenant has a pet without permission, whether to avoid fees or for some other reason, this should mark a serious violation. It's essential to know about the presence of pets, so you can best manage your property.


Be sure to check your insurance policy for restricted or “dangerous” dog breeds, and include those same restrictions in your pet policy. Many insurance companies levy large fees if the presence of a specific breed is detected, and that is something you will surely want to avoid. 


Get Support from Harrisburg Property Management Group


Need a sample pet policy? Wondering what to include in a rental policy? At Harrisburg Property Management Group, we can answer these questions and provide the expert support you need when you own properties in Harrisburg, Mechanicsburg, and the surrounding areas in PA. Renting to tenants with cats and dogs is an added challenge, but it’s one you can overcome with the right know-how. 


Contact us today about our management services and expert guidance for your property. 


By Ryan Colquhoun July 27, 2026
Learn when to sell your Harrisburg rental property with insights on cash flow, maintenance costs, vacancy rates and market trends. Contact us today.
By Ryan Colquhoun July 27, 2026
When you rent without professional property management, you could face costly legal issues, difficult tenants and long vacancy periods. You'll likely also spend a significant amount of time on paperwork and deal with delayed property maintenance. These issues can reduce your cash flow, increase stress and create compliance problems. 1. Tenant Screening Mistakes When you screen tenants yourself, you may overlook details that put you at risk of late rent, property damage and high turnover. Unreliable renters can also lead to costly evictions. Professional property managers implement meticulous screening and have the resources to run thorough background checks, assessing applicants: Credit scores Income Rental history References This helps you find quality tenants who pay on time and take care of your property, while saving you time and effort. 2. Legal Missteps and Noncompliance You must abide by your state's landlord-tenant laws. For example, landlords in Pennsylvania are required to follow the Fair Housing Act and provide a 10-day eviction notice for non-payment of rent. Noncompliance risks fines, disputes and legal delays. Professional property managers understand these regulations. They help you avoid violations and ensure proper documentation, protecting you from costly legal missteps and keeping your rental business compliant. 3. Delayed or Improper Maintenance When repairs are delayed or done incorrectly, you could face greater damage and unhappy tenants. Partnering with a property management company provides access to vetted contractors who perform preventive maintenance and repairs while staying within your budget. This ensures your property meets habitability standards, protects your return and maintains your reputation. Plus, they handle 24/7 tenant emergencies, so you don't have to. 4. Vacancy and Pricing Errors Undercharging means that you're losing out on income, whereas charging too much can lead to extended vacancies. Poor marketing and subpar listing photos can also negatively impact your rental's profitability. A property manager helps you set competitive rent using market data. They also use effective online and offline advertising to attract new tenants quickly, helping you reduce vacancy rates and increase rental income. 5. Time-Consuming Administrative Tasks Dealing with tenants, inspections, bookkeeping, and vendors can consume your time and increase the risk of errors. With property management, you can outsource tasks such as bill payment, rent collection and tax filings. Their expert systems protect cash flow, reduce stress and provide tax-ready records. This frees your time to focus on other things while enjoying your rental returns. Reduce Risk With Harrisburg Property Management Group For over a decade, Harrisburg Property Management Group has managed more than 2,000 rentals in Central Pennsylvania. We'll help you reduce risk with our marketing and leasing , tenant relations , property maintenance , and accounting and financial services . Contact us today to save your time and stress, while maximizing your rental's profitability.
April 21, 2026
Maximize rental income with expert property management. Set optimal rent, find quality tenants, and reduce costs for a profitable investment.
April 21, 2026
Hiring a property manager for one rental is worthwhile if your time is limited, you live far away or you're concerned about legal compliance risks.
April 21, 2026
Learn how property managers handle emergency maintenance calls, including response steps, timelines, and what qualifies as a true rental emergency.
By Paula Bauder June 5, 2025
Property management services can help you not only save time, but also save money and energy. Learn more about the benefits of property management.
If you're considering working with a property management company, we can help you get started. Learn
By Paula Bauder June 5, 2025
If you're considering working with a property management company, we can help you get started. Learn how to find a reliable property manager in your area.
By Ryan Colquhoun May 27, 2025
Prepare your property for tenants with a focus on inspections, cleaning, safety measures, competitive pricing, and effective advertising.
By Ryan Colquhoun February 12, 2025
Why should you hire a property management service? This blog explores the top five benefits of working with property management professionals.
By Ryan Colquhoun February 12, 2025
Want some quick tips on reducing vacancy rates for your rental property? Learn how a property management company can help you fill more units.