How Do I Avoid Renting to Bad Tenants?

Appfolio Websites • October 22, 2020
Hand holding a key with a house-shaped key chain dangling down

Guide to Avoiding Bad Tenants


Nightmare tenants keep you up at night. You take pride in the quality of your properties and the residents who live in them — you just wish they did, too.


Whether they don't pay rent on time, mistreat their rental units, falsify background information — or any other red flag waving during the tenant screening process — it falls on your shoulders to thoroughly find, vet, sort, and verify the good renters from the bad. As a current landlord yourself, these worries can lead to many headaches — and, worst-case scenario, legal battles and corrupted property portfolios.


In our tenant screening services for Harrisburg, Pennsylvania, and the surrounding areas, we've collected dozens of tricks, tips and legal advice to pick the right tenants for your rental property. We've condensed some of the best into a guide so you can steer clear of bad tenants who glitter but aren't gold.


1. Keep Your Ads Professional

Let's start off with a tip well within your control — your property's advertisements.

Irresponsible tenants or those with a history of not paying rent strategically look for ads signaling easy prey based on language and ad design. 


This isn't a scare tactic to make you second guess your online and print marketing. Rather, it's an easy and effective practice to attract good tenants with squeaky-clean credit scores and background checks.


Ensure all of your ads — digital and print — appear clear and professional. Use industry terms and upscale language when describing rental units. Include high-quality photos and even a management logo to signal your professionalism as a property owner or manager, as well as contact information for any property management companies that help oversee your complex.


Do not mention if your property has been vacant for extended periods of time, advertise numerous price reductions or state you're looking for an "immediate tenant." Sure, these might be true, but broadcasting this information is like taking bad prospective tenant's hands and personally inviting them to start a lease. Serious and responsible renters respond to serious and responsible advertisements. The opposite is also true.


2. Conduct a Strategic Prospective Tenant Screening Process


Many current landlords and property management companies understand the importance of screening tenants yet struggle to find natural yet thorough methods.


These early background checks are essential, providing your first line of defense against bad tenants.

Setting up an early meeting between landlords and prospective tenants is the best way to assess red flags before lengthier vetting procedures.


Try any of the following depending on what works best for your schedule and comfort levels:

  • Face-to-face meeting: Perhaps most constructive, a face-to-face meeting with a prospective tenant allows you to review the written lease, rent payment and collection protocol, income restrictions, and tenant jobs, plus answer any questions the prospective renter may have, such as whether you require renters insurance. You're also afforded a direct interaction with this individual, which managers know can prove invaluable.
  • Phone call: If a brief face-to-face meeting isn't possible, opt for a phone call. These give you the time to explicitly relay lease expectations and get a sense of an individual's communication style and personality.
  • Email: The courteousness and promptness of an individual's emails can say a lot about their potential as a renter. Consider email as yet another method to screen tenant applicants early.


Man points to sheet of paper while woman with kids looks at him

3. Avoid Yes or No Questions In-Person and in Rental Documents


Does your written lease or rental application include a generic list of yes or no questions? If so, you're missing a great way to sort good tenants from bad — especially those who will pay rent on time. 


Consider all the ways you can craft specific yet concise vetting questions across lease documents and in-person interactions. For example, rather than inquiring if the prospective individual has enough money to cover the first month's rent, application fee, and security deposit up-front, ask when they will be sending you these deposits. Instead of asking if they've rented in the past, ask for past landlords' contact information.


Tailoring written lease agreement and rental application language is an under-the-radar tip to avoid nightmare tenants and plays a huge role in qualifying. Yes-or-no questions will only go so far in making confident and comfortable resident decisions.


4. Use the First Showing to Steer Clear of Bad Tenants


There are so many ways to use the first showing to learn about the potential and pitfalls of a tenant.


Seasoned current landlords and property managers should note the following when showing a space to a prospective tenant for the first time:

  1. Timeliness: It's not exactly a ringing endorsement if a prospective tenant arrives late to their showing. Sure, it doesn't make them a bad person, but it does tarnish the impression of them as a responsible and proactive lessee you want to rent to.
  2. Demeanor and appearance: Does the prospective renter appear happy to be there and genuinely interested in the rental unit? do they ask questions and remain positive across tenancy agreements, application forms, and background checks? Or do they carry a "let's-get-this-over-with" mentality that's stand-offish and alarming?
  3. Shoes on or off: This is an industry trick as old as renting itself. Many managers assess the conscientiousness of renters by if they remove their shoes or not after entering the room. Decide for yourself if this means something and take note of other ways they interact with the space.
  4. State of their car: See if you can sneak a peek into the potential tenant's car. Is garbage strewn about, wrappers and bottles on the floor, and forgotten items stuffed into the back seat? It's likely the way they treat their vehicle reflects the way they'll treat your unit.
  5. Reactions when discussing rules of lease qualifications: How someone reacts when you review lease rules, tenant's credit scores, collecting rent payments on time, and any other renter requirements says a lot. Is the individual terse or responsive, casual or engaged, or perhaps even visibly annoyed or verbally hostile? Don't need to settle for the latter.


set of keys being handed over

5. Write a Rental Application Protecting From Terrible Tenants


At this point in the tenant screening process, you should hopefully have an indication of what kind of tenant an individual will be. Rental applications are not the only source of this information — or the last. But they are invaluable to deep-dive into history, qualifications, and the likelihood of paying rent on time.


The best rental applications will ask for the following:

  • Full name, birth date, and social security number 
  • Applicant's current job 
  • Applicant's monthly income and proof of income
  • Applicant's supervisor and their contact information
  • Current address and proof of address
  • Rental history, typically the last two to three places of residency
  • Landlord references
  • Other character references outside of family
  • Next-of-kin or primary and emergency contacts 
  • Permission statement to run full credit and background checks, including a criminal background check
  • Any additional information you may need to gather an informed renter's profile, such as pets, lawsuit history, and if they've sued past property managers.


Remember to go beyond blanket "yes" or "no" language with questions. If an applicant skips or keeps a section blank, don't jump to conclusions. Dedicate form space for them to detail extenuating circumstances or offer explanations for things that may not look great on paper.


6. Don't Slack on Research and Rental Application Verification

Another tip well within your control to avoid bad renters? Actually conduct a full-scale background screening with a credit check and eviction report.


While at times tenant screenings might seem alarmist and time-consuming, conducting the following background checks is the only way to verify a tenant's application. It backs up their answers and gives you confidence that you're renting to someone reliable — all because you yourself support a thorough screening process.


  • Look them up on social media: This nifty little trick isn't just for hiring managers. Landlords can learn about a person's lifestyle and what kind of renter they might be from a simple Facebook, Twitter, and LinkedIn search.
  • Income and supervisor follow-up: While it would be nice to trust the number the applicant reports, do your homework and call their employer directly. If an applicant is self-employed, a freelancer, or works as part of the growing gig economy, you'll need other means to verify income. Request a copy of last year's tax returns, employment contracts, bank records, or even the contact information of freelance clients so you can double-check numbers.
  • Job follow-up: Does the job or company named on the application actually exist? Yes, it seems unbelievable, but we've heard some landlord horror stories. A simple Internet search should suffice.
  • Past landlord follow-up: Just as you contact supervisors, reach out to their most recent landlord or two. Keep questions open-ended rather than yes or no, and ensure you're getting a sense of the prospective tenant's personality and reliability with paying rent. Note that if the tenant hasn't rented before or has moved around a lot, though it's not an immediate red flag. Just ensure you get an explanation of why.
  • Thorough background check: Conduct a nationwide criminal background check either on your own or with the help of a tenant-reporting agency.
  • Nationwide eviction history report: These can be run through a number of agencies, ensuring you have the real picture of an individual's rental past, plus match the information they provided on their application.
  • Full credit report: Both the tenant background check and a full credit report can be run by partnering with a credit bureau directly or a tenant-reporting agency.


small house figure sitting in the palm of someone's hand

7. Include a Mandatory Two-Way Move-In Report


Move-in reports are a great tool to further trust with your prospective tenants.


First, you'll want to conduct a private report using landlord forms immediately after the previous tenant moves out. You'll thoroughly review and take note of the condition of the rental unit, noting anything beyond normal wear and tear. Then, have the new tenant conduct their own report as early as possible after settling in. Review the two reports together for discrepancies.


A mandatory two-way report between a landlord and tenant has several benefits. For starters, if the tenant balks at reviewing reports side-by-side, this could be an indication they may be challenging down the road. Second, it provides a written and binding rental agreement that can be consulted later in the event of property damage disputes. Third, it gives you even more time to assess how the tenant takes responsibility and initiative — all win-wins on how to avoid bad tenants.


8. Conduct Regular Rental Site Inspections


Last but not least, it is essential to set up and maintain an annual or biannual rental unit inspection.

These inspections are not meant to be intimidating or overbearing for your tenants. They're a way to actually discourage nightmare tenants from applying to live in your properties. Instead, occasional site inspections are meant to bolster mutual respect for a space, both on your end and the tenant's. Good tenants understand this.


Ensure you provide written documentation and advanced notice of your site inspection schedule with tenants, then stick to it. While many landlords conduct a standard 24-hour's inspection notice, you can set yourself apart and further emphasize the responsibility you bear as a landlord by having a set inspection schedule. While under certain circumstances, landlords can enter residencies without that 24-hour notice or set schedule, these cases are rare and not something you want to operate under.


9. Partner With a Property Management Company With Experience in Tenant Relations


Whether you're new to real estate investing or an experienced investor, finding a property management partner will assist you with nearly every aspect of tenant applications, screenings and lease drafting, and it will lend greater peace of mind for all parties involved.


Opt for property management companies located where your properties are. Local rental management companies are more familiar with state and local property statutes, fair housing laws, taxes, ordinances, legal advice, real estate investment logistics, and more, which vary by region.


You'll also want to note their portfolio of managed properties. A company with a vested history in commercial real estate, not residential rentals or single-family homes, is likely not the right fit for you.


They can also provide the following services to lighten the daily load of your current landlord obligations:

  • Thorough tenant screenings, including background checks, credit reports and eviction history
  • Property accounting services, from managing rental payments to municipal account payments
  • Written lease preparation with accredited legal counsel and advice
  • Maintenance and emergency repairs, ideally around the clock
  • Tenant eviction and documenting eviction reports


Manipulative individuals or those with a track record of lousy leasing habits tend to stay clear of properties with an explicit management company relationship. Since these companies offer an extra layer of procedural and legal protection, it is much less likely that a bad tenant can get away with noncompliance.


Explore proper management companies in your area to see who fits your service needs and regional expertise. In many cases, you'll wonder how you ever got by without one.


Experienced Property Management Partners and Tenant Screenings in Harrisburg, Hershey and Beyond

Landlords in Pennsylvania have enough on their plates without the added anxieties of dealing with bad tenants. Harrisburg Property Management Group understands this. For years, we've been helping property owners in Harrisburg, Hershey, and other Central-Pennsylvania regions attract and retain their dream tenants — without bending over backward to do so.


Contact Harrisburg Property Management Today

From Pennsylvania tenant screening to lease preparation drafted with our knowledgeable legal counsel, we can offer some of the state's leading compliant property management services. Contact us today to see how we can help you find the perfect tenants for your hard-earned properties.

By Ryan Colquhoun • October 25, 2026
Whether you are selling your rental property to reinvest in another rental or put the money away in a retirement fund, you are likely hoping to walk away with capital gains. Capital gains are the profit resulting from the sale of an asset, particularly your investment property. In this article, we explain the types of capital gains, their tax implications and strategies for effectively managing them. For Harrisburg and Central Pennsylvania landlords, understanding capital gains on the sale of their rental property is critical to ensuring a profitable sale. The Two Types of Capital Gains There are two types of capital gains calculated on rental properties. Short-term capital gains apply to assets held for a year or less, and they are often taxed at the standard income tax rate. Long-term capital gains, on the other hand, apply to properties owned for more than a year and enjoy a preferential federal tax rate of up to 20%, depending on your taxable income. The longer you hold your property, the higher the chances of paying a lower capital gains tax. Calculating Your Rental Property's Gain To calculate the gain on your rental property, the first consideration should be the original cost basis. This is the initial cost of acquiring the property, including the purchase price, closing costs and any non-deductible expenses incurred during purchase. With the original cost basis, you can then calculate the adjusted basis. The adjusted basis is the original basis plus the cost of major improvements to the property that enhance its value or extend its useful life. If there are any reductions to the basis, factor them into the adjusted basis. The reductions could include casualty losses, easements granted and any depreciation allowable or taken. For example, if you bought a property for $250,000 and incurred acquisition costs of $5,000, your initial cost basis is $255,000. If during your ownership, you replaced the roof, added a deck and renovated the kitchen for a total of $45,000, these would be your capital improvements. For the sake of our calculations, let us consider a $30,000 depreciation taken. Step 1: Calculate the Net Sales Price Calculate the net sales price by subtracting your selling expenses from the gross sales price. If you are selling the property for $380,000 and incurred selling expenses of $20,000, then your net sales price would be $380,000 - $20,000 = $360,000. Step 2: Calculate the Adjusted Basis The adjusted basis will include your capital improvement and the original basis minus the depreciation claimed. According to our example, the adjusted basis is $255,000 + $45,000 - $30,000 = $270,000. Step 3: Calculate the Capital Gain For the capital gain, you will need to subtract the adjusted basis from the net sales price: $360,000 - $270,000 = $90,000. Decoding Depreciation Recapture Depreciation is the amount the IRS allows you to deduct each year for normal wear and tear, while recapture is the portion of that amount you must repay. If you sell your rental property for more than your adjusted basis, then the government will want to recapture the tax break it gave you during your ownership. Tax recapture applies even to depreciation allowable, not just taken. This tax is often subject to a special federal rate of up to 25% , but not more than your income tax rate. In our example, your total depreciation is $30,000. We will multiply it by the 25% to get the total recapture tax of $7,500 that the government will recoup. Federal vs. Pennsylvania Capital Gains Tax The federal government taxes capital gains at rates of either 0%, 15% or 20% . Your total taxable rate depends on your income bracket. For high-income earners, the government may also include an additional 3.8% net investment income tax. However, Pennsylvania has a different approach to taxes. Rather than taxing long- or short-term gains at different rates, the state applies a single standard rate to all net gains. The state doesn't charge a separate depreciation recapture, nor are there preferential rates. The state's 3.07% income rate applies to capital gains. Now, to calculate the total capital gains subject to tax, we don't start with the $90,000 because we have already calculated the $30,000 recapture. We start with the $60,000, which is the remaining capital gain. If you are in the 15% bracket, your tax would be $60,000 x 15% = $9,000. Add that to the depreciation recapture, and the total federal tax would be $9,000 + $7,500 = $16,500. For the Pennsylvania state tax, calculate the tax on the total gains. So, $90,000 x 3.07% = $2,763. Strategies to Minimize Capital Gains Tax While a capital gains tax is often mandatory, there are several strategies you can apply to minimize the total amount you have to pay. Timing your sale: Hold on to the property for at least a year. After a year, you are eligible for more favorable long-term capital gains. You can also align your sale with the year when you have a lower income to be in a lower federal tax bracket. 1031 exchange: If you reinvest the proceeds into a similar investment property, you can qualify for a federal deferment. This Section 1031 option allows you to defer both the capital gains and depreciation recapture taxes. You have 45 days to identify the replacement property and exactly 180 days to close. Convert to a primary residence: For two to five years before selling the rental, you may be able to convert it to a primary residence, allowing you to exclude up to $250,000 of the gain if single or $500,000 if married. However, do note that there are limitations, and you cannot exclude the depreciation recapture. Installment sale: You can also opt for the buyer to repay you in installments. This process enables you to spread the tax liability across those years, potentially keeping you in a lower tax bracket. Since the depreciation recapture is calculated in the year of sale, it will still apply. Avoid Common Pitfalls There are several pitfalls to watch for when working with capital gains: Ignoring state-specific rules: While federal laws apply nationwide, each state has its own unique laws that may affect capital gains or even exchange rules. Beyond federal laws, also investigate state-specific rules that apply to you. Inadequate record-keeping: Having accurate records is the best way to track expenses and improvements, making it easier to prove a higher adjusted basis. Poor timing: Selling without considering the impact on your tax bracket or market conditions may result in higher capital gains tax. Lack of professional advice: Whether federal or state-specific, tax laws are complex. Navigating them without professional help may make it easier to file the wrong form or even miss a due date. Partner With Harrisburg Property Management Group for a Smooth Sale Understanding capital gains on the sale of a rental property can help you navigate both federal and state-specific taxes. At Harrisburg Property Management Group, we are a comprehensive solution for landlords looking to sell a rental property in Central Pennsylvania and the surrounding areas. Our experience as a licensed real estate brokerage and property management company means we are there for you when you are leasing your property and when you need to sell it. We can help you conduct accurate property assessments that consider rental income potential and local market trends while streamlining the selling process. Contact our team and let us help you maximize the sale of your rental property. 
By Ryan Colquhoun • August 21, 2026
Selling an investment property with tenants in PA involves lease transfers, notice rules and more. Learn the process and your options today.
By Ryan Colquhoun • July 27, 2026
Learn when to sell your Harrisburg rental property with insights on cash flow, maintenance costs, vacancy rates and market trends. Contact us today.
By Ryan Colquhoun • July 27, 2026
When you rent without professional property management, you could face costly legal issues, difficult tenants and long vacancy periods. You'll likely also spend a significant amount of time on paperwork and deal with delayed property maintenance. These issues can reduce your cash flow, increase stress and create compliance problems. 1. Tenant Screening Mistakes When you screen tenants yourself, you may overlook details that put you at risk of late rent, property damage and high turnover. Unreliable renters can also lead to costly evictions. Professional property managers implement meticulous screening and have the resources to run thorough background checks, assessing applicants: Credit scores Income Rental history References This helps you find quality tenants who pay on time and take care of your property, while saving you time and effort. 2. Legal Missteps and Noncompliance You must abide by your state's landlord-tenant laws. For example, landlords in Pennsylvania are required to follow the Fair Housing Act and provide a 10-day eviction notice for non-payment of rent. Noncompliance risks fines, disputes and legal delays. Professional property managers understand these regulations. They help you avoid violations and ensure proper documentation, protecting you from costly legal missteps and keeping your rental business compliant. 3. Delayed or Improper Maintenance When repairs are delayed or done incorrectly, you could face greater damage and unhappy tenants. Partnering with a property management company provides access to vetted contractors who perform preventive maintenance and repairs while staying within your budget. This ensures your property meets habitability standards, protects your return and maintains your reputation. Plus, they handle 24/7 tenant emergencies, so you don't have to. 4. Vacancy and Pricing Errors Undercharging means that you're losing out on income, whereas charging too much can lead to extended vacancies. Poor marketing and subpar listing photos can also negatively impact your rental's profitability. A property manager helps you set competitive rent using market data. They also use effective online and offline advertising to attract new tenants quickly, helping you reduce vacancy rates and increase rental income. 5. Time-Consuming Administrative Tasks Dealing with tenants, inspections, bookkeeping, and vendors can consume your time and increase the risk of errors. With property management, you can outsource tasks such as bill payment, rent collection and tax filings. Their expert systems protect cash flow, reduce stress and provide tax-ready records. This frees your time to focus on other things while enjoying your rental returns. Reduce Risk With Harrisburg Property Management Group For over a decade, Harrisburg Property Management Group has managed more than 2,000 rentals in Central Pennsylvania. We'll help you reduce risk with our marketing and leasing , tenant relations , property maintenance , and accounting and financial services . Contact us today to save your time and stress, while maximizing your rental's profitability.
April 21, 2026
Maximize rental income with expert property management. Set optimal rent, find quality tenants, and reduce costs for a profitable investment.
April 21, 2026
Hiring a property manager for one rental is worthwhile if your time is limited, you live far away or you're concerned about legal compliance risks.
April 21, 2026
Learn how property managers handle emergency maintenance calls, including response steps, timelines, and what qualifies as a true rental emergency.
By Paula Bauder • June 5, 2025
Property management services can help you not only save time, but also save money and energy. Learn more about the benefits of property management.
If you're considering working with a property management company, we can help you get started. Learn
By Paula Bauder • June 5, 2025
If you're considering working with a property management company, we can help you get started. Learn how to find a reliable property manager in your area.
By Ryan Colquhoun • May 27, 2025
Prepare your property for tenants with a focus on inspections, cleaning, safety measures, competitive pricing, and effective advertising.